Chris Smith on Whether De Blasio’s Mayorship Can Play Nationally — New York Magazine
Bill de Blasio was late. This time it wasn’t his fault. State legislators lined as much as shake fingers and pose for images with New York’s latest political star earlier than permitting De Blasio to start out his testimony. Then they wished to share his televised highlight, quizzing the mayor about his pre-Ok tax-the-rich plans till his look earlier than Albany’s funds committees stretched practically two and a half hours. Finally De Blasio was despatched off, to a ready pack of reporters, with a teasing farewell from Denny Farrell, the rascally octogenarian Democratic assemblyman.
“There’s a whole bunch of people waiting for you,” Farrell stated with a sly chuckle.
“Are they pleasant individuals?” De Blasio replied with a goofy heh heh heh.
In mid-December, in Washington, a gaggle of fellow mayors-elect had let De Blasio take the lead in chatting with the press after a White House assembly with President Barack Obama. Now, in Albany, the mayor’s subsequent assembly was an extra—if much more difficult—ratification of his hovering political stature. Governor Andrew Cuomo, as a substitute of letting De Blasio come and go from his house turf with out remark, had instantly scheduled a joint press convention, ostensibly to promote their frequent want to save lots of Brooklyn hospitals. The mayor, when he spoke, was cautious to defer to the governor. But as the 2 sat elbow to elbow, grinning and backslapping with honest affection, it was simple to marvel simply whose present this actually was.
In some methods it’s wildly out of proportion: By advantage of operating and profitable because the left-most candidate in a Democratic major in a overwhelmingly Democratic metropolis, Bill de Blasio has change into a nationwide determine. But politics is as a lot hype and artwork as it’s science. And so De Blasio is now a beacon to liberals throughout the nation. Which is why his native skirmish with Cuomo is about far more than easy methods to fund prekindergarten enlargement. It’s about competing visions of the Democratic Party, and it’s a foreshadowing of a pressure that would form the 2016 presidential primaries.
Some of the De Blasio impact is customary political flattery, the type of factor that occurs at any time when a candidate wins an upset on a giant stage. In New Orleans, two challengers to incumbent Mitch Landrieu peddled a “tale of two cities” (they misplaced anyway). Seattle’s new mayor, Ed Murray, is assembling an “income inequality committee” and pushing for a $15 minimal wage. The Newark City Council simply handed a invoice mandating paid sick go away; comparable laws is gaining floor in California, Massachusetts, Nebraska, Oregon, and Vermont. De Blasio fellow vacationers are even turning up in purple states: Republican governors in Alabama, Indiana, and New Mexico, of their 2014 State of the State speeches, trumpeted initiatives to spend extra money on prekindergarten.
Were all of them impressed by De Blasio? No. And De Blasio himself is as a lot egg as he’s rooster, cannily capitalizing on a development whose roots are within the 2008 monetary meltdown, Occupy Wall Street, and the rise of Elizabeth Warren. Something was already taking place on the market. The query, particularly for nationwide Democrats, is how large and deep the shift is and will likely be. Certainly the left is investing nice hope in its new hero. “Bill de Blasio is now seen as the flagship for a potential urban-policy enlightenment,” says Adam Green, a co-founder of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, the million-member group that was a key early fund-raiser for Warren. “If he is successful at making New York benefit everyday, working-class people, that could have huge ripple effects, very quickly, across the nation.”
A big indicator will come this fall, as Democrats attempt to maintain on to their U.S. Senate majority. John Del Cecato, the De Blasio media strategist who crafted the well-known “Dante” advert, is working on one of many extra intriguing races, and his candidate is one other populist from Brooklyn—Brooklyn, Iowa. Bruce Braley, at the moment a Democratic congressman, is operating for the U.S. Senate seat being vacated by Tom Harkin, and the race will flip on Iowa-centric points. But Braley will present an attention-grabbing take a look at of how progressive themes play within the heartland.
Top nationwide Democrats dismiss the concept that De Blasio’s priorities at the moment are driving the political agenda. “We’re still focused on economic fairness and opportunity for the middle class,” one strategist says. The government director of the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee, Guy Cecil, factors out that each contest has its personal dynamics, and that the specifics of De Blasio’s playbook aren’t readily transferable. “In most of our races, it’s not necessarily about creating balance by raising taxes in the way that De Blasio is doing it,” Cecil says. “The prescription for the problem isn’t the same.” Instead, he stresses conventional Democratic political talismans like preserving Medicare and Social Security. Yet Cecil says that De Blasio’s message could be very a lot in sync with what’s taking place nationally. “I do think, overall, there is a common theme about people who are at or near the poverty line, and those who are squarely in the middle class, are getting the raw end of the deal,” Cecil says. Where De Blasio harped on inexpensive housing, he says, Senate candidates are highlighting “pocketbook issues” like faculty loans that resonate with goal constituencies, like Latino voters. “I don’t know that an election in New York City is having any impact on this conversation, as much as it might be reflecting where the larger country is,” Cecil says, “which is that we are seeing the stock market rise, and we’re seeing business starting to grow, and GDP starting to improve—and at the same time there are a lot of Americans who in their daily lives are not seeing the benefit.”
Cecil’s studying of the panorama is necessary not only for Democratic Senate candidates this 12 months, however as a result of he’s prone to be on the quick checklist to run Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential bid, if she certainly runs. At this level she’s the prohibitive favourite to change into the nominee—although that was true on the similar level within the run-up to 2008, earlier than most individuals noticed Barack Obama coming. “I assume there will be a primary challenge from the left, for sure,” Howard Dean says—although he additionally says it gained’t be by him: “There are a lot of pragmatic progressives, and I’m one of them, who are supporting her.” Dean campaigned for De Blasio final 12 months, and he says that what occurs at City Hall can have ramifications far past the town. “Two progressive mayors—Bill and Eric Garcetti, in Los Angeles—don’t make a landslide toward progressivism. But I do think progressivism in general is gaining the ascendancy in this country,” Dean says. “Bill has to be mayor first, and he has to do a good job, and I think he will. But what he does is very important to the progressive movement. The rap on the progressive movement—mostly from the Wall Street types—is they can’t run anything, they can’t balance the budget. That’s not true. We’ve done a much better job than the Republicans of balancing the budget. Look at Bill Clinton.”
Andrew Cuomo realized an incredible deal within the service of the Great Triangulator, and he’s hardly the one Democrat who believes that discuss of a drastic shift to the left is overstated, significantly contemplating that De Blasio’s “mandate” was delivered by a skinny slice of the voters. Cuomo genuinely respects De Blasio and desires him to succeed as mayor. But he has staked his governing strategy and his political profession on being a centrist, a minimum of by New York requirements, and for 4 years Cuomo has largely been a welcome drive for budgetary sanity. Now, although, he’s navigating a change within the political wind. “Jeff Klein was never thought of as lefty, but he’s pretending to be one now,” a Cuomo adviser says of the Democrat who has set himself up as an influence dealer within the State Senate. “Klein, De Blasio, Eric Schneiderman, and Shelly Silver being allied weirds out Cuomo. He wants to be Mr. Moderate, and these guys are pulling him down the path of the ultraliberal stuff.” Cuomo’s response can be, as with most eachfactor involving the governor, tied to the psychodrama of being the son of Mario Cuomo, a person whose high-minded rhetoric made him a hero of the left; Andrew is set to make his mark with deeds, not phrases. Cuomo’s camp scoffs at De Blasio’s moralizing lefty tone, the mayor’s discuss of being on a “sacred mission.” “He acts as if income inequality is a higher purpose,” a Cuomo ally says. “ ‘We’re not talking about filling potholes. We’re talking about social justice.’ Bill’s been a pragmatist his whole career. You don’t really think he’s changed, right?”
The substance and politics of the subsequent few months are essential for the mayor. Resolving his pre-Ok battle with Cuomo will assist outline whether or not preventing for a tax enhance on the rich is an effective Democratic gambit. Yet it’s De Blasio’s high-stakes negotiations with labor unions that will likely be much more telling. Shifting metropolis authorities’s values to the left gained’t matter if De Blasio can’t get the dollars and cents proper and finally ends up changing into a spendthrift captive of the outdated Democratic curiosity teams. But if De Blasio succeeds, his model of progressivism will acquire credibility, and the mayor will change into a valued validator for liberals suspicious of HRC ’16. And if someway Hillary doesn’t run, Cuomo might discover his friendship with De Blasio particularly helpful.
E-mail: [email protected]